I liked Allison's version, because she seemed to put that "white girl soul singer" spin on the song (GAH, now I sound like Randy ;p ) She was actually the first person I've heard since Carrie who sounded like she wasn't trying to imitate Carrie. To me, it didn't sound "pop."
(But Kelly was much prettier...Allison seems like an old soul for only being 16. :/ )
Contemporary-sounding!?!? Seriously!?!?
Hee, don't you know in Idol time, 5-10 years ago is contemporary? :p But honestly, I can see the emo rock thing, too (all those guys wear makeup and guyliner), but even that's been around for 5 years!! Yeesh.
Oh, and did you hear that Casey -- FUCKING CASEY!!! -- came out bitching about Carla and talking trash about her.
OH NO SHE DIDN'T. :o That is just...horrible. :( Poor Carla. From everything I've read, Hosea won through luck and Richard Blais. And I really liked Richard in his season, too, but...blech. Couldn't have helped a worse contestant. :/
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 2009-02-26 09:48 pm (UTC)(But Kelly was much prettier...Allison seems like an old soul for only being 16. :/ )
Contemporary-sounding!?!? Seriously!?!?
Hee, don't you know in Idol time, 5-10 years ago is contemporary? :p But honestly, I can see the emo rock thing, too (all those guys wear makeup and guyliner), but even that's been around for 5 years!! Yeesh.
Oh, and did you hear that Casey -- FUCKING CASEY!!! -- came out bitching about Carla and talking trash about her.
OH NO SHE DIDN'T. :o That is just...horrible. :( Poor Carla. From everything I've read, Hosea won through luck and Richard Blais. And I really liked Richard in his season, too, but...blech. Couldn't have helped a worse contestant. :/