For those who read the rewatch-reviews, a question ...

[arabian]

I've said I'm doing the "Rose" episodes, but I was thinking of throwing in those episodes I really, really liked as well ("Blink," "Utopia," a few other S4 episodes). Should I (even if like with "Utopia" I wouldn't bother with the following two parter)? Or should I just keep it to the "Her Name was Rose" collection as previously listed?

Comments

[mysticalchild_isis]

If you're so inclined, I say go for any episodes you feel like reviewing. I'm always interested to see what other people have to say for all the episodes.

[time-converges.livejournal.com]

I've enjoyed reading the ones you've done so far - I'll read any you decide to do!

[yenly-gozal.livejournal.com]

If you really like them, then why not? You can write them separately. So it might not be part of "Her name was Rose" collection.

[blackcat-1.livejournal.com]

I thought that 'Utopia' would be in your collection anyway, as there are are some very strong Rose refs in that ep.

[arabian.livejournal.com]

I wanted to do that -- actually, I wanted to put "Utopia" in my actual collection to rewatch -- but I'm such a stickler (even in this case) for it making sense and without the two-parter afterwards (or even "Smith and Jones" and "The Shakespeare Code" to explain why Martha is there), it just wouldn't flow for me.

I was even thinking of (for myself) doing episode synopses videos of certain episodes and then including them ... but I don't know.

As you can see, I'm very anal about this. So, yeah, I just decided to stick with episodes where Rose actually makes an appearance (flashbacks in "The Runaway Bride" count, but the quick flashes in "The Sontaron Strategy" and "Midnight" wouldn't count, but I really, really love "Midnight, and there are two other references to Rose, so I'm still debating on that one).

See? Anal.

[logicisfailing.livejournal.com]

Your reviews are always well thought out, I say go ahead if you feel like reviewing those as well! (though your 'Rose' episodes are the most special of course :-D